Thursday May 17

A3K Club Login

[Review] Mushi-shi: The Movie

Attention: open in a new window. PDFPrintE-mail
Review by: Josh Dunham Director: Katsuhiro Otomo Animation Production: Oriental Light and Magic Distributed by: Funimation   With any film adaptation, a certain amount of excitement fills viewers with hopes of the movie being wonderful, while the same amount of dread is also present of how horrible it may turn out.   This divides viewers into two groups. One group wishes only for an accurate portrayal of the original work, with total disregard for how horribly it may affect the movie. The other merely wants the film to flow well, with not butchering the original work being a bonus. Whether or not viewers will enjoy Mushi-Shi hinges not so much on which side of the line they fall on, but on their familiarity with Japanese culture.

 

Steeped in mysticism and Japanese folklore and taking place in rural Japan, Mushi-Shi has the distinct feel of a foreign film. Add that with traditions that may not translate well to American audiences, Mushi-Shi can come off as odd and childish instead of whimsical, which is its biggest drawback for casual audiences. On the other hand, those who are somewhat knowledgeable with Japanese customs will be able to overlook these obstacles, allowing for an easier viewing experience.

Having been directed by veteran director Katsuhiro Otomo, (Akira, Steamboy)  who has an outstanding track record for making good adaptations, the film does well in portraying the original Mushi-Shi, to the point that it may turn off fans who didn’t enjoy the manga, while fans who did will only find it that much more enjoyable. Though not perfect, the feel of the series as a whole comes intact.

One of the biggest stumbling blocks for Japanese films in the American market is dubbing; however, Mushi-Shi overcomes this with incredible ease. All the lines are properly timed, without rushing or strange over/under emphasizing of words. The chosen voices match each actor’s appearance, especially the main character, Ginko. Of course, the DVD also allows it to be viewed with subtitles in the original Japanese as well.

However, the length of the film is a speed bump in its road to glory. Stretching over two hours in length, Mushi-Shi is quite an involvement compared to those used to 90 minute features. Unlike other two-hour anime films that constantly have something going on, Mushi-Shi feels the need to stop a breath every so often, before deciding to pick back up again. Mixed with its slow start that does little to move the story along and somber mood, it can be a trial of endurance to watch it all in one setting. That is not to say that the film is boring, but rather that it is something more to be experienced than simply viewed.

Overall, Mushi-Shi is a wonderful film, but it may have a hard time reaching out to those unfamiliar to Japanese culture. Audiences used to the different style of filming will find a smart and intriguing story full of supernatural happenings without having to deal with over-the-top action, which will engage their minds. Viewers wanting a faithful portrayal of the original won’t be disappointed, while others looking another great film will find something worthwhile as well. That is, assuming they can sit through the whole thing.

Rating: C+

 


Josh Dunham
Written on Wednesday, 27 January 2010 07:37 by Josh Dunham

Viewed 3137 times so far.
Like this? Tweet it to your followers!
blog comments powered by Disqus

A3K Partners

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

A3K Programming

2 Guys and a Mic
A3K Panel
A3K Podcast
A3K Radio
A3K Radio
Anime Addicts Anonymous
Anime Pulse
Anime World Order
Anime Zone
Aniriffs!
Bonus Round
Fightbait Anime Podcast
Fightbait Anime Podcast
Fightbait Anime Podcast
Method to Madness
The Speakeasy
The Other Side